Supreme Court Takes Up Case About Privacy In Digital Age



AP Photo/File

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court is taking up a case about privacy rights that could limit the government's ability to track Americans' movements in the digital age.

The justices are hearing an appeal Wednesday from Timothy Carpenter. He was sentenced to 116 years in prison after being convicted of robbing electronics stores in Michigan and Ohio. Records from cellphone towers near the stores helped place Carpenter in the vicinity of the crimes.

The big issue is whether police must get a search warrant to look at the records. Rights groups and technology experts are among those who have joined Carpenter in arguing it's too easy for authorities to use the records to learn intimate details of someone's life.

The Supreme Court in recent years has acknowledged technology's effects on Americans' privacy. In 2014, the court held unanimously that police must generally get a warrant to search the cellphones of people they arrest. Other items people carry with them may be looked at without a warrant, after an arrest.

In Carpenter's case, authorities obtained cellphone records for 127 days.

The robberies took place at Radio Shack and T-Mobile stores in 2010 and 2011. Carpenter organized most of the robberies, in which he signaled the others in his group to enter the stores with their guns drawn, according to the government's Supreme Court brief. Customers and employees were herded to the back and the robbers filled their bags with new smartphones. They got rid of the guns and sold the phones, the government said.

Police learned of Carpenter's involvement after a confession by another person involved in the holdups. They got an order for cellphone tower data for Carpenter's phone, which shows which towers a phone has connected with when used in a call. The records help approximate someone's location.

Investigators were able to get a judge to sign an order for the records, but they had to meet a lower standard of proof than a warrant's requirement to show probable cause that Carpenter committed a crime.

Courts around the country have wrestled with the issue. The most relevant Supreme Court case is nearly 40 years old, before the dawn of the digital age, and the law on which prosecutors relied to obtain the records dates from 1986, when few people had cellphones.

The judge at Carpenter's trial refused to suppress the records, and a federal appeals court agreed. The Trump administration said the lower court decisions should be upheld.

The administration relied in part on a 1979 Supreme Court decision that treated phone records differently than the conversation in a phone call, for which a warrant generally is required.

The court said then that people had no expectation of privacy in the records of calls made and kept by the phone company. That case involved a single home telephone.

By Mark Sherman, Associated Press 

Add your comment:
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit ModuleShow Tags

Calendar

  • Strictly Biz Night

    2018.06.21

    Looking to promote your business and network with local professionals? Register today for Biz New Orleans' Strictly Biz Night. Join us this month...

  • Biz Night at the Jung Hotel

    2018.06.21

    Looking to promote your business and network with local professionals? Then register today for Strictly Biz Night presented by Biz New Orleans...

  • Biz Night at The Jung

    2018.06.21

    Join Biz New Orleans at the beautiful newly re-opened Jung Hotel & Residences to swap business cards and network with local professionals. Enjoy...

  • FestiGals Women's Weekend Experience

    2018.06.21

    The 2018 FestiGals Weekend will bring women of all ages and backgrounds together for an enjoyable experience that will feature authentic New...

  • FestiGals Tricentennial Women's Day

    2018.06.22

    The Tricentennial Women's Day at Jung Hotel and Residences of the New Orleans Hotel Collection is an empowering day full of incredible women...

  • FestiGals Step Up Second-Line Parade

    2018.06.22

    Being a woman is something to celebrate! So join us in the city’s largest women’s second-line parade to STEP UP to stop domestic violence....

  • Louisiana SPCA Volunteer Orientation

    2018.06.23

    The first step to becoming a volunteer with us is to attend the Louisiana SPCA Volunteer Orientation! Our work would not be possible without the...

  • Deutsches Haus Social

    2018.06.29

    The Deutsches Haus Social on Friday, June 29, 2018 will present the New Orleans Symphony Chorus’ Beer Choir. This will be a sing-a-long with...

  • RedRover Responders Volunteer Training.

    2018.06.30

    RedRover Responders Volunteer Training: RedRover provides an emergency safety net for animals when and where they need it most. The RedRover...

  • Rock, Ride and Rescue

    2018.07.08

    Rock, Ride and Rescue is a fundraiser to support animals with special needs at the Louisiana SPCA! Join us at Rock N Bowl on July 8 from 6 - 9 p.m....

  • RUNNING OF THE BULLS KICK OFF DINNER

    2018.07.12

    Olé! Kick off Festival de San Fermin (Running of the Bulls) with this special Spanish-themed wine dinner. Enjoy a fabulous four-course dinner with...

  • Raising the Steaks

    2018.07.18

    Class up your Wednesday at the Foundation Room VIP Club at House of Blues New Orleans. The iconic venue is partnering with award-winning classical...

  • Hispanic Business Conference & Tradeshow

    2018.08.08

    The Hispanic Business Conference and Trade Show is the premiere venue for Hispanic Businesses to market their goods and services and it is the...

  • Hispanic Business Conference & Tradeshow

    2018.08.08

    The Hispanic Business Conference and Trade Show is the premiere venue for Hispanic Businesses to market their goods and services and it is the...

  • Hispanic Business Conference & Tradeshow

    2018.08.08

    The Hispanic Business Conference and Trade Show is the premiere venue for Hispanic Businesses to market their goods and services and it is the...


Show More...