LMTA Seeks To Put An End To Phantom Medical Expenses



 

NEW ORLEANS — LMTA's HB 789 by Rep. Major Thibaut (D-New Roads) is scheduled for 9:00 a.m. Monday April 16 in the House Civil Law Committee.

This bill was brought on behalf of LMTA to put an end to phantom medical expenses, a key factor as to why so few insurance providers will do business in Louisiana. As an example, a medical procedure may be billed to an injured party and/or their insurer for $200,000 with $100,000 in "write-offs or write-downs." The plaintiff and his private or public insurer are only responsible for paying $100,000. Yet, the plaintiff can sue and will recover the $200,000 from the defendant. Louisiana auto accidents are nearly twice as likely to have "injuries" than the national average - that means our industry is paying twice as many phantom damages.

Here are some key facts:

  • The courts currently allow plaintiffs to recover medical expenses that were never actually paid by anyone. In the trucking industry, this is called "phantom damages" because they aren't real. 
  • As an example, a medical procedure may be billed to an injured party and/or their insurer for $200,000 with $100,000 in "write-offs or write-downs." The plaintiff and his private or public insurer are only responsible for paying $100,000. Yet, the plaintiff can sue and will recover the $200,000 from the defendant.
  • The number of auto accidents in Louisiana is slightly higher than the national average, but the number of accidents with "injuries" in Louisiana is about twice the national average. That means twice as many phantom damages facing the trucking industry. 
  • Knowing that we face phantom medical expenses, particularly in the common cases where it’s "his word versus mine" on fault, trucking companies can't risk going to trial. Our insurers will settle almost every time. This drives up insurance costs tremendously. 
  • Some trucking companies are starting to install cameras on trucks to help defend themselves, but this is very costly and as long as plaintiffs are entitled to phantom damages, frivolous lawsuits will keep coming and Louisiana will have higher than average accidents with "injuries." 
  • This bill simply ensures that plaintiffs are able to recover their actual medical expenses. It does nothing to the many other recoverable items such as wages, earning capacity, etc. 
  • The argument against this bill is that defendants shouldn't enjoy the benefit of reduced medical expenses that an insured plaintiff gets. This is a flawed argument because everyone must be insured and the "write-offs or write-downs" are pre-established business arrangements between the insurer and the health care provider. Opponents of this bill are only seeking to maintain the "phantom damages" windfall. 
  • Opponents will also say that they need more than the actual medical cost to help cover attorney fees. This isn't true because the courts make a plaintiff whole before they make an insurer whole. If there isn't enough money, the insurance company ends up taking the hit not the plaintiff.
  • Lawyers can argue over technicalities all day on this issue, and that's the problem. It's very simple - defendants should pay for the actual cost of medical expenses. 

Add your comment:
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit ModuleShow Tags

Calendar

  • 2018 Regional Infrastructure Conference Construction Management Association of America (CMAA) Gulf Coast Chapter (GCC)

    2018.08.16

    Join the Construction Management Association of America – Gulf Coast Chapter (CMAA GCC) for the 2018 Regional Infrastructure Conference being...

  • COOLinary

    2018.08.01

    During the month of August, experience cuisine that delights your palate and is an integral part of the history and culture of New Orleans. This...

  • Upcoming Auditions Near New Orleans, LA

    2018.08.20

    To schedule an audition, please visit the website provided, https://ait.careers. Any questions about current or upcoming auditions should be...

  • Biz Night at Galatoire's 33

    2018.08.22

    Looking to promote your business and network with local professionals? Register today for Biz New Orleans' Strictly Biz Night. Join us this month...

  • The Boys & Girls Clubs of Southeast Louisiana’s “Blue Door Blues” Gala

    2018.08.23

    The Boys & Girls Clubs of Southeast Louisiana is proud to announce its annual fundraiser, “Blue Door Blues.” The gala, scheduled for Thursday,...

  • Fund 17 Summer Happy Hour

    2018.08.24

    This fall, Fund 17 will open a new resource center for entrepreneurs. Join us for a networking happy hour and exclusive look at the plans for this...

  • Networking Happy Hour

    2018.09.05

    Join us for the next installment in our quarterly New Orleans networking event series! We’re opening our doors and inviting the regional bio,...

  • Jefferson Chamber Golf Classic

    2018.09.20

    Enjoy a day on the links with business friends, clients or prospects, and network with Jefferson Chamber leadership, board members and key decision...

  • Spice of Life Women's Expo Northshore

    2018.09.22

    Bring your friends to shop, socialize and learn at this fun-filled, energetic Ladies Day Out. Exciting Speakers Presenting Interesting and Relevant...

  • You Are Not Alone

    2018.09.25

    The Counseling Solutions program of Catholic Charities Archdiocese of New Orleans is collaborating with the Substance Addiction Ministry of the...

  • Biz Night at Royal Sonesta

    2018.11.14

    Looking to promote your business and network with local professionals? Register today for Biz New Orleans' Strictly Biz Night. Join us this...


Show More...